Suggestions by @horrorobsessed
419 suggestions
Lindsay Hollister
as Fanny in The Auctioneer
Score: +1
Esmé Bianco
as Virginia Guthrie in The House Next Door
Score: +2
Judy Pace
as Odessa Redd in The Elementals
Score: +1
Emmy Rossum
as Mariana Andros in The Maidens
Score: 0
Richard Madden
as Duncan Phair in Gilded Needles
Score: +1
Sean Astin
as Rev. Edward Stallworth in Gilded Needles
Score: +1
Lara Jean Chorostecki
as Agnes Cogswell in The Auctioneer
Score: +1
Mark Donovan
as Gilg in Plaguewalker
Score: +1
Bernadette Peters
as Gerta in Plaguewalker
Score: +1
Lance Henriksen
as Old Sam Perry in The Auctioneer
Score: +1
Joshua Leonard
as Mickey Cogswell in The Auctioneer
Score: +1
Charlayne Woodard
as Odessa Redd in The Elementals
Score: 0
Gillian Jacobs
as Leigh Savage in The Elementals
Score: +2
Hettienne Park
as Jessica Landis in Fantasticland
Score: +1
Joseph Quinn
as Deputy Harlan in William Gay’s Twilight
Score: +1
Caroline Dhavernas
as Mim Moore in The Auctioneer
Score: +1
Austin Abrams
as Chase Pounder in Fantasticland
Score: +1
Henry Zebrowski
as Ernie Owens in Dead and Buried
Score: +1
Devon Weetly
as Sam McVey in Fantasticland
Score: 0
Jaheem Toombs
as Sam McVey in Fantasticland
Score: +2