Suggestions by @user_284948

Mckenna Grace

as Anne Wright in In The Pines

Score: +2

Joseph Quinn

as James Shaw in In The Pines

Score: +2

Florence Pugh

as Elizabeth Shaw in In The Pines

Score: +2

Margot Robbie

as Mary in Enemy (2003)

Score: +1

Emma Stone

as Helen Claire in Enemy (2003)

Score: +1

Adam Driver

as Carl in Enemy (2003)

Score: +1

Matt Bomer

as Jonathan Largo in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +1

David Harbour

as Principal Evans in Dawn to Dusk

Score: -1

Mason Thames

as James Williamson in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +3

Walker Scobell

as Jason in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +3

Mallory James Mahoney

as Emma Osborne in Dawn to Dusk

Score: -3

Kingston Foster

as Emma Osborne in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +1

Ruby Rose Turner

as Emma Osborne in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +3

Finn Carr

as Ethan Largo in Dawn to Dusk

Score: -3

Parker Bates

as Ethan Largo in Dawn to Dusk

Score: -3

Walker Scobell

as Ethan Largo in Dawn to Dusk

Score: -3

Ella Anderson

as Emma Osborne in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +1

Logan Lerman

as Reverend Hank Matthews in Dawn to Dusk

Score: -1

Nicholas Hoult

as Reverend Hank Matthews in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +1

Andrew Garfield

as Reverend Hank Matthews in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +1