Suggestions by @user_284948

Logan Lerman

as Reverend Hank Matthews in Dawn to Dusk

Score: -1

Nicholas Hoult

as Reverend Hank Matthews in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +1

Andrew Garfield

as Reverend Hank Matthews in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +1

Jack Dylan Grazer

as William Osborne in Dawn to Dusk

Score: -2

Levi Miller

as William Osborne in Dawn to Dusk

Score: -2

Jaeden Martell

as William Osborne in Dawn to Dusk

Score: -1

Chris Pine

as Officer Roy in Dawn to Dusk

Score: 0

Pedro Pascal

as Officer Roy in Dawn to Dusk

Score: 0

Adam Driver

as Officer Roy in Dawn to Dusk

Score: 0

Robert Pattinson

as Officer Roy in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +2

Richard Madden

as Officer Roy in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +1

Sebastian Stan

as Officer Roy in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +2

Lily James

as Haven Osborne in Dawn to Dusk

Score: 0

Lucy Hale

as Haven Osborne in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +1

Elizabeth Olsen

as Haven Osborne in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +1

Merritt Patterson

as Haven Osborne in Dawn to Dusk

Score: -2

Alexander Ludwig

as William "Will' Osborne in Dawn to Dusk

Score: -1

Alexander Skarsgård

as William "Will' Osborne in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +3

Eiza González

as Lucy Largo in Dawn to Dusk

Score: +4

Sofia Carson

as Lucy Largo in Dawn to Dusk

Score: -1