Suggestions by @guccigang

Zac Efron

as Ken in Barbie Alternate Casting (2023)

Score: +3

Tanner Buchanan

as Conrad in The Summer I Turned Pretty Series

Score: -1

Shia LaBeouf

as Shuya Nanahara in Battle Royale (2008)

Score: +1

Robert Pattinson

as Kazuo Kiriyama in Battle Royale (2008)

Score: +1

Rowan Atkinson

as Alfred Pennyworth in James Gunn DCU

Score: -1

Gavin Casalegno

as David in The Bible

Score: +2

Mateo Arias

as Jesus in The Bible

Score: -9

Evan Peters

as Abel in The Bible

Score: +6

Andrew Garfield

as Cain in The Bible

Score: -2

Zach Galligan

as Hiroki Sugimura in Battle Royale (80s)

Score: +1

Ralph Macchio

as Nobu in Battle Royale (80s)

Score: +2

Brooke Shields

as Mitsuko Souma in Battle Royale (80s)

Score: +2

Molly Ringwald

as Noriko Nakagawa in Battle Royale (80s)

Score: +2

Jim Carrey

as Keita Iijima in Battle Royale (80s)

Score: +2

Jason Patric

as Shogo Kawada in Battle Royale (80s)

Score: +2

Johnny Depp

as Kazuo Kiriyama in Battle Royale (80s)

Score: +2

Mason Gooding

as "Shogo Kawada" in Battle Royale

Score: +1

Matthew Broderick

as Shinji Mimura in Battle Royale (80s)

Score: +2

Gene Wilder

as Kitano in Battle Royale (80s)

Score: +2