Suggestions by @guccigang

Zac Efron

as Oliver in Mighty Med (2003)

Score: +1

Shia LaBeouf

as Kaz in Mighty Med (2003)

Score: +1

Miles Teller

as Wade Watts in Ready Player One (2008)

Score: +1

Noel Fisher

as Eddie Munson in Stranger Things Recast

Score: +1

Corey Feldman

as Ashtray in Euphoria 1982

Score: +1

Paul Dano

as William Afton in Five Nights at Freddy's (2033)

Score: +1

Jaeden Martell

as Mike Schmidt in Five Nights at Freddy's (2033)

Score: +1

Gene Wilder

as William Afton in Five Nights at Freddy's (1973)

Score: -3

Harrison Ford

as Mike Schmidt in Five Nights at Freddy's (1973)

Score: +1

Adam Driver

as Spencer Shay in iCarly (2017-2022)

Score: +4

Josh Hutcherson

as Mark in Let Me In (2008)

Score: +1

Matthew Lillard

as Alex Jones in Prisoners (2003)

Score: +3

Jim Caviezel

as Keller Dover in Prisoners (2023)

Score: 0

Johnny Depp

as Alex Jones in Prisoners (1983)

Score: +2

Tom Holland

as Alex Jones in Prisoners (2023)

Score: +4

Cole Sprouse

as Owen in Let Me In (2008)

Score: +1

Zac Efron

as Jimmy in Let Me In (2008)

Score: +1

Robin Williams

as Thomas in Let Me In (2008)

Score: +1

Christopher Briney

as Harry Osborn in Marvel Cinematic Universe

Score: -1

Ryan Gosling

as Human Torch in Fantastic Four(2005)-Alternate Cast

Score: +1