Suggestions by @zoeg

Robert Englund

as Rory in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Bill Skarsgård

as Demon in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Audrey Grace Marshall

as Annabelle Bee Mullins in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Iain Armitage

as Student in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +2

Brad Dourif

as Father Gorden in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Jackson Robert Scott

as Anothony Rios in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Logan Thompson

as Bob Palmeri in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Jennifer Tilly

as Luda Mae in Texas Chainsaw Massacre

Score: +2

Lucas Grabeel

as Lietenant Lefty in Texas Chainsaw Massacre

Score: +1

Morgan Freeman

as Radiop Announcer in Texas Chainsaw Massacre

Score: +2

Nicholas Hamilton

as Jerry in Texas Chainsaw Massacre

Score: +1

Jaeden Martell

as Kirk in Texas Chainsaw Massacre

Score: +1

Owen Teague

as The Hitch Hiker in Texas Chainsaw Massacre

Score: +1

Finn Wolfhard

as Chop Top in Texas Chainsaw Massacre

Score: +1

Dick Van Dyke

as Grandpa Sawyer in Texas Chainsaw Massacre

Score: +2

Jeremy Ray Taylor

as Franklin Hardesty in Texas Chainsaw Massacre

Score: +2

Mackenzie Ziegler

as Vanita in Texas Chainsaw Massacre

Score: +2

Sophia Lillis

as Pam in Texas Chainsaw Massacre

Score: +2

Millie Bobby Brown

as Sally Hardesty in Texas Chainsaw Massacre

Score: +2

Brad Dourif

as Drayton Sawyer in Texas Chainsaw Massacre

Score: +2