Suggestions by @zoeg

Samuel L. Jackson

as Marcus in Halloween (2018) Recast

Score: +1

Halle Berry

as Caretaker in Halloween (2018) Recast

Score: +1

Wyatt Oleff

as Cameron Elam in Halloween (2018) Recast

Score: 0

Jamie Lee Curtis

as Laurie Strode in Halloween (2018) Recast

Score: +2

Nick Castle

as Michael Myers in Halloween (2018) Recast

Score: 0

Chris Pratt

as Parent At School in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Jared Leto

as Black Shuck in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Patrick Wilson

as Ed Warren in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +2

Sophia Lillis

as Nurse in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Vera Farmiga

as Lorraine Warren in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Devin Ratray

as Truck Driver in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Devin Sidell

as Truck Driver in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: -1

Matthew Cardarople

as Pizza Guy in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Wyatt Oleff

as Thomas in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Keanu Reeves

as Coin Corpse in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Millie Bobby Brown

as Mary Ellen in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Sadie Sink

as Nurse 2 in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Scarlett Johansson

as Flashback Bride in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Sofia Bryant

as Daniella Rios in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: +1

Mckenna Grace

as Judy Warren in Annabelle Comes Home

Score: 0