Suggestions by @williamvisnosky

Michael Clarke Duncan

as Apocalypse in X-Men (1996)

Score: +2

Ethan Suplee

as The Blob in X-Men (1996)

Score: +4

Paul Rudd

as Iceman in X-Men (1996)

Score: +1

John Goodman

as Beast in X-Men (1996)

Score: +1

Seth Green

as Banshee in X-Men (1996)

Score: +1

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Angel in X-Men (1996)

Score: +1

Ving Rhames

as Bishop in X-Men (1996)

Score: +1

Angela Bassett

as Storm in X-Men (1996)

Score: +1

Neve Campbell

as Shadowcat in X-Men (1996)

Score: +1

Denise Richards

as Jean Grey in X-Men (1996)

Score: +1

Helena Bonham Carter

as Rogue in X-Men (1996)

Score: +1

Johnny Depp

as Gambit in X-Men (1996)

Score: +3

Kurt Russell

as Cable in X-Men (1996)

Score: +1

Neil Patrick Harris

as Nightcrawler in X-Men (1996)

Score: +1

Arnold Schwarzenegger

as Colossus in X-Men (1996)

Score: +1

Jim Carrey

as Morph in X-Men (1996)

Score: 0

Patrick Stewart

as Professor X in X-Men (1996)

Score: +1

Matt Damon

as Cyclops in X-Men (1996)

Score: +2

Mel Gibson

as Wolverine in X-Men (1996)

Score: +1

James Cameron

as Director in X-Men (1996)

Score: +1