Suggestions by @wholockedholmes

Ryan Reynolds

as Deacon in Fallout 4 - Live Action Fancast

Score: +10

Grant Gustin

as John Martin in Random Fancasts

Score: +1

Peter Stormare

as Giles Corey in The Crucible - Play Fancast

Score: +1

Rebecca Ferguson

as Elizabeth Proctor in The Crucible - Play Fancast

Score: +2

Elizabeth Marvel

as Ann Putnam in The Crucible - Play Fancast

Score: +1

David Harbour

as Thomas Putnam in The Crucible - Play Fancast

Score: +1

Charlotte Rampling

as Rebecca Nurse in The Crucible - Play Fancast

Score: +1

Beanie Feldstein

as Mary Warren in The Crucible - Play Fancast

Score: +1

Jason Isaacs

as Reverend Samuel Parris in The Crucible - Play Fancast

Score: +1

Lily Rabe

as Elizabeth Proctor in The Crucible - Play Fancast

Score: +2

Hugh Dancy

as Reverend John Hale in The Crucible - Play Fancast

Score: +1

Julia Garner

as Abigail Williams in The Crucible - Play Fancast

Score: +2

Michael Fassbender

as John Proctor in The Crucible - Play Fancast

Score: +1

Zazie Beetz

as Tilly Jackson in Red Dead Redemption II - Live Action Fancast

Score: +3

Summer Fontana

as Sarah in The Last Of Us - Live Action Fancast

Score: +3

Sam Heughan

as Billy Lee in Bad Times At The El Royale - Fancasts

Score: +5

Gary Sinise

as Madrake in The Leaf Men - 'Epic' 2013 Live Action Fancast

Score: +2

Armie Hammer

as Billy Lee in Bad Times At The El Royale - Fancasts

Score: +7

Jimmy Simpson

as Kieran Duffy in Red Dead Redemption II - Live Action Fancast

Score: +1

Christopher Plummer

as Professor X in Random Fancasts

Score: +1