Suggestions by @wholockedholmes

Clancy Brown

as Captain Quint in Jaws - Reboot Fancast

Score: +3

James Ransone

as Hooper in Jaws - Reboot Fancast

Score: +4

Idina Menzel

as Voice of the Blue Fairy in A.I. Artificial Intelligence

Score: +2

Alex Kingston

as Dolores Umbridge in Random Fancasts

Score: +1

Griffin Gluck

as Bobble in Pixie Hollow - Tinker Bell Fancast

Score: 0

Laz Alonso

as Husker in Broken Age - Live Action Fancast

Score: +2

Liam McIntyre

as The Deep in The Boys - Fancast

Score: +5

Matt Ryan

as Translucent in The Boys - Fancast

Score: +3

Michael Mando

as Translucent in The Boys - Fancast

Score: +6

Morena Baccarin

as Popclaw in The Boys - Fancast

Score: +9

Anson Mount

as Homelander in The Boys - Fancast

Score: +3

Cobie Smulders

as Queen Maeve in The Boys - Fancast

Score: +9

Liev Schreiber

as Billy Butcher in The Boys - Fancast

Score: +2

Millie Bobby Brown

as Carmelita Spats in Random Fancasts

Score: +1

Lana Parrilla

as Emse Squalor in Random Fancasts

Score: +1

Cobie Smulders

as Kit Snicket in Random Fancasts

Score: +1

Danielle Panabaker

as Kit Snicket in Random Fancasts

Score: +1

Pedro Pascal

as Jacques Snicket in Random Fancasts

Score: +1

Christopher Eccleston

as Lemony Snicket in Random Fancasts

Score: +1

Willem Dafoe

as Count Olaf in Random Fancasts

Score: +1