Suggestions by @whocares2

Joan Allen

as Pat Nixon in PRESIDENT

Score: +2

Glenn Close

as Anna Harrison in PRESIDENT

Score: +2

Annette Bening

as Hillary Clinton in PRESIDENT

Score: +1

Annette Bening

as Martha Washington in PRESIDENT

Score: +1

Helena Bonham Carter

as Dolley Madison in PRESIDENT

Score: +1

Colin Jost

as Napoleon Bonaparte in PRESIDENT

Score: +1

Kit Harington

as Alexander Hamilton in PRESIDENT

Score: +1

Rhys Ifans

as John Jay in PRESIDENT

Score: +1

Joaquin Phoenix

as John Adams in PRESIDENT

Score: 0

Joaquin Phoenix

as Aaron Burr in PRESIDENT

Score: +1

Annette Bening

as Abigail Adams in PRESIDENT

Score: +1

Jeff Daniels

as John Marshall in PRESIDENT

Score: +1

Annette Bening

as Martha Washington in PRESIDENT

Score: +1

Martin Freeman

as James Madison in PRESIDENT

Score: 0

Chris O'Dowd

as James Monroe in PRESIDENT

Score: +2

Chris O' Donnell

as James Monroe in PRESIDENT

Score: +1

Chris O'Dowd

as James Monroe in PRESIDENT

Score: +1

Chris O'Neil

as James Monroe in PRESIDENT

Score: +1

Bill Camp

as Benjamin Franklin in PRESIDENT

Score: +1

Hugh Laurie

as Thomas Jefferson in PRESIDENT

Score: +1