Suggestions by @whocares2

Timothée Chalamet

as Franklin Pierce in American Presidents(story private)

Score: +1

Alec Baldwin

as Millard Fillmore in American Presidents(story private)

Score: +1

Ian McShane

as Zachary Taylor in American Presidents(story private)

Score: +1

Tom Hiddleston

as James K. Polk in American Presidents(story private)

Score: +1

Tim Roth

as John Tyler in American Presidents(story private)

Score: +1

James Cromwell

as William Henry Harrison in American Presidents(story private)

Score: +1

Matthew Modine

as Andrew Jackson in American Presidents(story private)

Score: +1

Terence Stamp

as John Quincy Adams in American Presidents(story private)

Score: +1

Chris O'Dowd

as James Monroe in American Presidents(story private)

Score: +1

Martin Freeman

as James Madison in American Presidents(story private)

Score: +1

Henry Cavill

as Thomas Jefferson in American Presidents(story private)

Score: +1

Paul Giamatti

as John Adams in American Presidents(story private)

Score: +1

Michael Douglas

as George Washington in American Presidents(story private)

Score: +1