Suggestions by @vaulthunter

Evan Rachel Wood

as Jenna Hunterson in Waitress The Musical: Movie Reimagining

Score: +4

Amber Riley

as Becky in Waitress The Musical: Movie Reimagining

Score: +5

Erin Moriarty

as Heather McNamara in Heathers The Musical: Movie Reimagining

Score: +2

Naomi Scott

as Veronica Sawyer in Heathers The Musical: Movie Reimagining

Score: +1

Hailee Steinfeld

as Heather Duke in Heathers The Musical: Movie Reimagining

Score: +1

Beanie Feldstein

as Martha Dunstock in Heathers The Musical: Movie Reimagining

Score: +2

Sabrina Carpenter

as Heather McNamara in Heathers The Musical: Movie Reimagining

Score: +2

Zendaya

as Veronica Sawyer in Heathers The Musical: Movie Reimagining

Score: -1

Natasia Demetriou

as Mad Moxxi in Borderlands

Score: -1

Zoé De Grand Maison

as Bonnie Parker in Bonnie and Clyde: The Musical

Score: -1

Timothy Olyphant

as Handsome Jack in Borderlands

Score: +18

Jade Hassouné

as Tyrannus Basilton Grimm-Pitch in Carry On

Score: -13

Mackenzie Foy

as Stephanie Edgley in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: -2

Courtney Eaton

as Eve Kingston in EVE: The Awakening

Score: +1

Julia Garner

as Harley Quinn in DCEU Rebooted

Score: -4

Tati Gabrielle

as Maxine "Max" Gibson in Batman Beyond

Score: +15

Leah Lewis

as Dana Tan in Batman Beyond

Score: +3

Jonah Hauer-King

as Terry McGinnis in Batman Beyond

Score: -11

Julianne Hough

as Bonnie Parker in Bonnie and Clyde: The Musical

Score: -1