Suggestions by @vaulthunter
773 suggestions
Jessie Mueller
as Emma in The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals
Score: -1
Janelle Monáe
as Mariah Reynolds in Hamilton: An American Movie
Score: +1
Zoë Kravitz
as Peggy Schuyler in Hamilton: An American Movie
Score: 0
Zendaya
as Peggy Schuyler in Hamilton: An American Movie
Score: +3
Jacob Elordi
as Clark Kent in The Superman (2021)(story removed)
Score: -1
Jennifer Hudson
as Becky in Waitress The Musical: Movie Reimagining
Score: +6
Ryan Gosling
as Dr. Jim Pomatter in Waitress The Musical: Movie Reimagining
Score: +2
Dianna Agron
as Jenna Hunterson in Waitress The Musical: Movie Reimagining
Score: +8
Chris Pine
as Earl Hunterson in Waitress The Musical: Movie Reimagining
Score: +2
Bradley Cooper
as Earl Hunterson in Waitress The Musical: Movie Reimagining
Score: +3
Shannon Purser
as Martha Dunstock in Heathers The Musical: Movie Reimagining
Score: +1
Emily Blunt
as Jenna Hunterson in Waitress The Musical: Movie Reimagining
Score: 0
Joseph Gordon-Levitt
as Dr. Jim Pomatter in Waitress The Musical: Movie Reimagining
Score: +2
Amanda Seyfried
as Dawn Louise Pinkett in Waitress The Musical: Movie Reimagining
Score: -1
Ben Platt
as Ogie Herbert Eincorn in Waitress The Musical: Movie Reimagining
Score: +1
Kate Rockwell
as Charity Barnum in The Greatest Showman
Score: +1
Naomi Scott
as Dawn Louise Pinkett in Waitress The Musical: Movie Reimagining
Score: +1
Lily James
as Jenna Hunterson in Waitress The Musical: Movie Reimagining
Score: +2
Zachary Levi
as Dr. Jim Pomatter in Waitress The Musical: Movie Reimagining
Score: +2
Deborah Ann Woll
as Jenna Hunterson in Waitress The Musical: Movie Reimagining
Score: -1