Suggestions by @user_233048

Vincent Price

as Bowser in Super Mario Bros

Score: +6

Frank Welker

as Yoshi in Super Mario Bros

Score: +2

Jim Cummings

as Toad in Super Mario Bros

Score: +2

Melissa Manchester

as Princess Peach in Super Mario Bros

Score: +2

Dom DeLuise

as Luigi in Super Mario Bros

Score: +4

Freddie Jones

as Mario in Super Mario Bros

Score: +2

Bill Murray

as Sammy Lawrence in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +1

Daniel Radcliffe

as Lurker in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +1

Dan Aykroyd

as Dewey in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +1

Tabitha St. Germain

as Carley in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +1

Cherilyn Sarkisian

as Alice Angel in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +1

Victor Garber

as Bendy in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +1

Huell Howser

as Boris in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +1

K. Todd Freeman

as Edgar in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +1

Colin Baker

as Barley in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +1

Andrew Kishino

as Charley in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +1

Alex Brightman

as Tom in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +1

Paul Schoeffler

as Joey Drew in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +1

Tara Strong

as Allison in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +1

James Caan

as Henry in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +1