Suggestions by @user_233048

Jonathan Banks

as Nightmare BB in Fnaf 4: Halloween Special

Score: +1

Alan Rickman

as Nightmarrionne in Fnaf 4: Halloween Special

Score: +1

Christopher Plummer

as Nightmare Fredbear in Fnaf 4: Halloween Special

Score: +1

Kelly Sheridan

as Nightmare Mangle in Fnaf 4: Halloween Special

Score: +1

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Jack O Chica in Fnaf 4: Halloween Special

Score: +1

Alden Ehrenreich

as Jack O Bonnie in Fnaf 4: Halloween Special

Score: +1

Colman Domingo

as Nightmare Freddy in Fnaf 4: Halloween Special

Score: +1

Marta Svetek

as Evan in Fnaf 4: Halloween Special

Score: +1

Paul Hikari

as Sheriff Toadster in Garten of Banban 7

Score: +1

Ghepo

as Banban in Garten of Banban 7

Score: +1

Groucho Marx

as Greyli in Fnaf Movie

Score: -1

Alan Menken

as Composer in Fnaf Movie

Score: +1

Burny Mattinson

as Choreographer in Fnaf Movie

Score: +1

John Musker

as Writer in Fnaf Movie

Score: +1

Ron Clements

as Producer in Fnaf Movie

Score: +1

Don Bluth

as Director in Fnaf Movie

Score: +1

Thurl Ravenscroft

as Golden Freddy in Fnaf Movie

Score: +1

Burt Reynolds

as Foxy in Fnaf Movie

Score: +1

Loni Anderson

as Chica in Fnaf Movie

Score: +1

Barrie Ingham

as Bonnie in Fnaf Movie

Score: +1