Suggestions by @teshabarnes

Clive Barker

as Director in Clive Barker's Saw II (1995)

Fairuza Balk

as Amanda Young in Clive Barker's Saw (1994)

Henry Rollins

as Eric Matthews in Clive Barker's Saw II (1995)

Tobey Maguire

as Spider-Man in Spider-Man 4

Clive Barker

as Director in Clive Barker's Saw (1994)

Brad Dourif

as Zepp Hindle in Tobe Hooper's Saw (1974)

Tobin Bell

as Billy the Puppet in Clive Barker's Saw (1994)

Tony Todd

as John Kramer (Jigsaw) in Clive Barker's Saw III (1996)

Richard Roundtree

as David Tapp in Clive Barker's Saw (1994)

Danny Glover

as David Tapp in Clive Barker's Saw (1994)

Tim Robbins

as Lawrence Gordon in Clive Barker's Saw (1994)

Brad Dourif

as Zepp Hindle in Clive Barker's Saw (1994)

Desmond Harrington

as Adam Faulkner in Clive Barker's Saw (1994)

Cary Elwes

as Lawrence Gordon in Clive Barker's Saw (1994)

Tobin Bell

as John Kramer (Jigsaw) in Clive Barker's Saw (1994)

Fairuza Balk

as Amanda Young in Clive Barker's Saw III (1996)