Suggestions by @teshabarnes

Drew Carey

as Ivan Landsness in Clive Barker's Saw IV (1997)

Ashley Judd

as Addison Corday in Clive Barker's Saw IV (1997)

Costas Mandylor

as Mark Hoffman in Clive Barker's Saw IV (1997)

Richard Jenkins

as Rex in Clive Barker's Saw IV (1997)

John Goodman

as Paul in Clive Barker's Saw (1994)

Kevin Gage

as Jeff Reinhart in Clive Barker's Saw IV (1997)

Rosario Dawson

as Lindsey Perez in Clive Barker's Saw IV (1997)

Joe Pesci

as Art Blank in Clive Barker's Saw IV (1997)

Betsy Russell

as Jill Tuck in Clive Barker's Saw IV (1997)

Henry Rollins

as Eric Matthews in Clive Barker's Saw IV (1997)

Tobin Bell

as John Kramer (Jigsaw) in Clive Barker's Saw IV (1997)

Mario Van Peebles

as Rigg in Clive Barker's Saw IV (1997)

Ethan Suplee

as Timothy Young in Clive Barker's Saw III (1996)

Michael Emerson

as Zepp Hindle in Clive Barker's Saw (1994)

Ashley Judd

as Addison Corday in Clive Barker's Saw II (1995)

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Allison Kerry in Clive Barker's Saw II (1995)

Mario Van Peebles

as Rigg in Clive Barker's Saw II (1995)

Fairuza Balk

as Amanda Young in Clive Barker's Saw II (1995)

Tobin Bell

as Billy the Puppet in Clive Barker's Saw II (1995)

Tobin Bell

as John Kramer (Jigsaw) in Clive Barker's Saw II (1995)