Suggestions by @saracuda

Huck (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Henry (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Gigi (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Frobert (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Drift (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Diva (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Croque (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Cousteau (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Camofrog (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Zucker Animal Crossing

as Octopus in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Octavian (Animal Crossing)

as Octopus in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Marina (Animal Crossing)

as Octopus in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +3

Cephalobot (Animal Crossing)

as Octopus in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Nadja of Antipaxos

as Vampire in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Nandor the Relentless

as Vampire in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Laszlo Cravenworth

as Vampire in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Deacon

as Vampire in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Vladislav

as Vampire in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Viago

as Vampire in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Bill Compton

as Vampire in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1