Suggestions by @saracuda

C.J. (Animal Crossing)

as Beaver in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Turanga Leela

as Cyclops in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Scott McCall

as Werewolf in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +2

Alcide Herveaux

as Werewolf in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +2

Princess Fiona

as Ogre in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: -1

Richard Parker (Life of Pi)

as Tiger in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Mike the Tiger

as Tiger in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Mabel (Animal Crossing)

as Hedgehog in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Sable (Animal Crossing)

as Hedgehog in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Label (Animal Crossing)

as Hedgehog in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +2

Khonshu

as God/Goddess in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Wart Jr. (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Tad (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Ribbot (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Raddle (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Puddles (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Prince (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Lily (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Jeremiah (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1

Jambette (Animal Crossing)

as Toad in Sorting Fictional characters by Species

Score: +1