Suggestions by @reidburger

Alan Ritchson

as Carl in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: -8

Jack Quaid

as Jim in The Mayor of Noobtown

Score: +1

Patrick Stewart

as Porthus in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: +6

Diego Luna

as Anton in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: +3

Michael Peña

as Paz in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: +3

Martha Higareda

as Sister Ines in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: 0

Peter Dinklage

as Quasar in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: -2

Christina Hendricks

as Madison in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: +4

Gemma Chan

as Li Na in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: +4

Maggie Q

as Lexis in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: +3

Millie Bobby Brown

as Rosetta in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: -4

Julianne Moore

as Astrid in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: +2

Elizabeth Banks

as Cascadia in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: +10

Channing Tatum

as Brad in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: +2

Katey Sagal

as Carl's Mom in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: +6

Patrick Warburton

as Carl's Father in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: +22

Jessica Matten

as Gwen in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: -1

Erin Moriarty

as Britney in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: -2

Gina Torres

as Queen Imogen in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: -2

Monica Bellucci

as Meriam Dom in Dungeon Crawler Carl

Score: +9