Suggestions by @randomcaster
563 suggestions
Abe Lincoln (Clone High)
as Will Forte in Best character each of these actors played
Boingo
as Andy Dick in Best character each of these actors played
Mr. Fox (Fantastic Mr. Fox)
as George Clooney in Best character each of these actors played
The Beyonder
as Laurence Fishburne in Best character each of these actors played
Eugene Harold Krabs
as Clancy Brown in Best character each of these actors played
Phineas Flynn
as Vincent Martella in Best character each of these actors played
Randall Boggs
as Steve Buscemi in Best character each of these actors played
Gumball Watterson
as Nicolas Cantu in Best character each of these actors played
Rochelle Hillhurst
as Keke Palmer in Best character each of these actors played
Ellie Williams
as Bella Ramsey in Best character each of these actors played
Norville "Shaggy" Rogers
as Matthew Lillard in Best character each of these actors played
Lunella Lafayette (Moon Girl)
as Diamond White in Best character each of these actors played
Captain Marvel (Carol Danvers)
as Brie Larson in Best character each of these actors played
Thanos (The Mad Titan)
as Josh Brolin in Best character each of these actors played
Sherlock Holmes (BBC)
as Benedict Cumberbatch in Best character each of these actors played
Captain America (MCU)
as Chris Evans in Best character each of these actors played
Norma Khan
as Kody Kavitha in Best character each of these actors played
J. Jonah Jameson
as J.K. Simmons in Best character each of these actors played
Batman (DCEU)
as Ben Affleck in Best character each of these actors played
Aquaman
as Jason Momoa in Best character each of these actors played