Suggestions by @paulcoolman

Matthew McConaughey

as Hosea Matthews in Red Dead Origins

Score: +1

Mickey Rourke

as Colt Seavors in The Fall Guy (1994)

Score: +2

Oscar Isaac

as Rick Dalton in Coen Brothers' Once Upon a Time... In Hollywood

Score: +1

Ben Foster

as Jake Wise in Against All Odds (2014)

Score: +1

Orson Welles

as Vito Corleone in Recasting Marlon Brando

Score: +3

Matthew McConaughey

as Butch Cassidy in Butch Cassidy & The Sundance Kid (2019)

Score: 0

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as Arthur Morgan in Red Dead Origins

Score: +1

Dylan O'Brien

as Linus Caldwell in Ocean's Trilogy ('21-'27)

Score: +1

Matthew McConaughey

as Rick Deckard in Almost Cast: Blade Runner

Score: +3

Dylan O'Brien

as Billy Costigan Jr. in Almost Cast: The Departed

Score: +3

James Mangold

as Director/Creator in The Last Van Der Linde: A Red Dead Story

Score: +2

Josh Hartnett

as Middle-Aged Jack Marston in The Last Van Der Linde: A Red Dead Story

Score: +1

George Clooney

as Mickey Pearson in The Gentlemen (2010)

Score: +2

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Michael "Mickey" Pearson in The Gentlemen (2025)

Score: +2

Matthew McConaughey

as Paul Newman in Deceased Celebrity Look Alikes

Score: +4

The Godfather

as Films that should NOT be remade in To Remake or Not To Remake?

Score: +11

Ester Expósito

as David Corenswet in Actors/Actresses Who Should Play Love Intrestests Of Each Other ?

Score: +2

Hailee Steinfeld

as David Corenswet in Actors/Actresses Who Should Play Love Intrestests Of Each Other ?

Score: +2

Oscar Isaac

as Colt Seavers in The Fall Guy (2024)

Score: +4

Billy Campbell

as Clark Kent in Superman (1995)

Score: +7