Suggestions by @paulcoolman

Jesse Eisenberg

as Jimmy Olsen in Superman (2015)

Score: +5

Rachel McAdams

as Lois Lane in Superman (2015)

Score: +7

Anne Hathaway

as Lois Lane in Superman (2015)

Score: +10

Channing Tatum

as Superman in Superman (2015)

Score: +7

Catherine Zeta-Jones

as Frank & Grace's Father & Mother in Two To Tango

Score: +3

Brendan Fraser

as Frank & Grace's Father & Mother in Two To Tango

Score: +3

Spoiler

as Frank & Grace's Father & Mother in Two To Tango

Score: +3

Brad Pitt

as Producer in Two To Tango

Score: +2

Damien Chazelle

as Director in Two To Tango

Score: +3

Emma Stone

as Hedy Warren in Two To Tango

Score: +3

Ana de Armas

as Grace Roberts-Delany in Two To Tango

Score: +3

Miles Teller

as Ed Driver in Two To Tango

Score: +3

Taron Egerton

as Ben Hanover in Two To Tango

Score: +3

Nikita Efremov

as Patrick Belikov in Two To Tango

Score: +3

LaKeith Stanfield

as Carl Abolaji in Two To Tango

Score: +3

Daniel Kaluuya

as Carl Abolaji in Two To Tango

Score: +4

Alexander Skarsgård

as James Cornwall in Two To Tango

Score: +3

David Corenswet

as Frank Delany in Two To Tango

Score: +3

Sharon Stone

as Cat Grant in Uncasted Superman Characters for the Christopher Reeve Films

Score: +2

Taylor Sheridan

as Director in Red Dead Redemption 3

Score: +1