Suggestions by @oldchatot
1,268 suggestions
Rupert Penry-Jones
as Ingwë in The Silmarillion
Henry Cavill
as Fëanor in The Silmarillion
Jeremy Irvine
as Dior in The Silmarillion
Sebastian Stan
as Beren Erchamion in The Silmarillion
Harris Dickinson
as Maeglin in The Silmarillion
Cole Sprouse
as Amras in The Silmarillion
Chris Hemsworth
as Galdor of Dor-lómin in The Silmarillion
Josh Dallas
as Celegorm in The Silmarillion
Ian McKellen
as Olórin in The Silmarillion
Michael Sheen
as Húrin in The Silmarillion
Kate Beckinsale
as Morwen Eledhwen in The Silmarillion
Richard Armitage
as Finwë in The Silmarillion
Justin Hartley
as Huor in The Silmarillion
Stephen Amell
as Barahir in The Silmarillion
Daniel Di Tomasso
as Caranthir in The Silmarillion
Brett Dalton
as Caranthir in The Silmarillion
Lily Mo Sheen
as Nienor in The Silmarillion
Matt Bomer
as Curufin in The Silmarillion
Gustaf Skarsgård
as Olwë in The Silmarillion
Hugo Weaving
as Elros in The Silmarillion