Suggestions by @oldchatot
1,268 suggestions
Idris Elba
as Aulë in The Silmarillion
Joaquin Phoenix
as Mîm in The Silmarillion
Javier Bardem
as Mîm in The Silmarillion
Ken Davitian
as Mîm in The Silmarillion
Alan Ritchson
as Tulkas in The Silmarillion
Mark Strong
as Mandos in The Silmarillion
Barbara Palvin
as Nellas in The Silmarillion
Àstrid Bergès-Frisbey
as Nellas in The Silmarillion
Irina Starshenbaum
as Nellas in The Silmarillion
Wilf Scolding
as Elrond in The Silmarillion
Charlie Hunnam
as Mahtan in The Silmarillion
Anne Hathaway
as Melian in The Silmarillion
Charlize Theron
as Anairë in The Silmarillion
Hailee Steinfeld
as Rían in The Silmarillion
Cressida Bonas
as Nerdanel in The Silmarillion
Margaret Qualley
as Lúthien in The Silmarillion
Garrett Hedlund
as Maedhros in The Silmarillion
Alexander Skarsgård
as Elwë in The Silmarillion
Ben Barnes
as Gil-galad in The Silmarillion
Dylan Sprouse
as Amrod in The Silmarillion