Suggestions by @ninewheels

André De Shields

as The Arbiter in Chess (musical)

Score: -1

Shea Whigham

as Walter in Chess (musical)

Score: +2

Patrick Page

as Molokov in Chess (musical)

Score: +6

Kelsey Grammer

as Molokov in Chess (musical)

Score: +2

Michelle Williams

as Svetlana Sergievsky in Chess (musical)

Score: -1

Aaron Tveit

as Freddie Trumper in Chess (musical)

Score: +6

Dan Stevens

as Freddie Trumper in Chess (musical)

Score: -1

Adam Driver

as Anatoly Sergievsky in Chess (musical)

Score: -1

Oscar Isaac

as Anatoly Sergievsky in Chess (musical)

Score: 0

Anne Hathaway

as Florence Vassy in Chess (musical)

Score: +3

Mark Rylance

as Polonius in Hamlet

Score: +3

Terrence Mann

as Polonius in Hamlet

Score: +1

Richard Jenkins

as Polonius in Hamlet

Score: +1

Richard E. Grant

as Ghost in Hamlet

Score: +1

Stephen Dillane

as Ghost in Hamlet

Score: +2

Patrick Page

as Ghost in Hamlet

Score: +2

Alfred Enoch

as Horatio in Hamlet

Score: +2

Evan Peters

as Horatio in Hamlet

Score: +3

Elizabeth McGovern

as Gertrude in Hamlet

Score: +4

Alex Kingston

as Gertrude in Hamlet

Score: +2