Suggestions by @ninewheels

Ellen Burstyn

as Aunt May in Spider-Man

Score: -1

Olivia Taylor Dudley

as Black Cat in Spider-Man

Score: -3

Sam Waterston

as Uncle Ben in Spider-Man

Score: -6

Anna Shaffer

as Mary Jane Watson in Spider-Man

Score: -15

Dev Patel

as Peter Parker in Spider-Man

Score: -22

Melissa Benoist

as Kathy in Company - The Musical

Score: +2

America Ferrera

as Marta in Company - The Musical

Score: +1

Betsy Wolfe

as April in Company - The Musical

Score: +1

Danny Burstein

as Larry in Company - The Musical

Score: +1

Allison Janney

as Joanne in Company - The Musical

Score: +3

Benjamin Walker

as Paul in Company - The Musical

Score: +1

Anna Kendrick

as Amy in Company - The Musical

Score: +1

Jane Krakowski

as Susan in Company - The Musical

Score: +1

Raúl Esparza

as Peter in Company - The Musical

Score: 0

Lin-Manuel Miranda

as David in Company - The Musical

Score: +1

Annaleigh Ashford

as Jenny in Company - The Musical

Score: +2

Amber Gray

as Sarah in Company - The Musical

Score: +1

Alan Tudyk

as Harry in Company - The Musical

Score: +1

Dan Stevens

as Bobby in Company - The Musical

Score: +1

Jon Jon Briones

as The Arbiter in Chess (musical)

Score: +1