Suggestions by @nathanialprice

Anthony Carrigan

as Procrustes in 🔱Percy Jackson and the Olympians🔱

Score: +9

Jon Bernthal

as Ares in 🔱Percy Jackson and the Olympians🔱

Score: +11

Dean-Charles Chapman

as Peter Pettigrew in All the Young Dudes

Score: -48

Charles Dance

as Barty Crouch Sr. in Harry Potter and the Mysteries of Hogwarts (2023-2030)

Score: +1

Charles Dance

as Barty Crouch Sr. in Harry Potter (Perfect Casting)

Score: +2

Charles Dance

as Bartemius Crouch Sr. in Harry Potter Television Series

Score: +3

Charles Dance

as Barty Crouch Sr. in Harry Potter: The Limited Series

Score: +3

Charles Dance

as Barty Crouch Sr. in Harry Potter: A TV Series (2009)

Score: +1

Charles Dance

as Barty Crouch Sr in Harry Potter and the goblet of fire

Score: +1

Charles Dance

as Barty Crouch Sr. in The First Wizarding War

Score: +4

Richard Madden

as Dmitri Karamazov in The Brothers Karamazov

Score: +3

Charlie Heaton

as Barty Crouch Jr in The Marauders Era

Score: 0

Thomas Brodie-Sangster

as Evan Rosier in The Marauders Era

Score: +3

Dev Patel

as James Potter in The Marauders Era

Score: -1

Dean-Charles Chapman

as Peter Pettigrew in The Marauders Era

Score: -1

Keeley Hawes

as Minerva McGonagall in The Marauders Era

Score: +3

Kaya Scodelario

as Andromeda Tonks in The Marauders Era

Score: -1

Bill Skarsgård

as Lord Voldemort in The Marauders Era

Score: +2

Fionn Whitehead

as Severus Snape in The Marauders Era

Score: 0

Ellie Bamber

as Narcissa Malfoy in The Marauders Era

Score: -1