Suggestions by @nathanialprice

Paul Newman

as Martin Brenner in Stranger Things (1983)

Score: +1

Diane Lane

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things (1986)

Score: +16

Amanda Bearse

as Barb Holland in Stranger Things (1983)

Score: +1

Eric Stoltz

as Jonathan Byers in Stranger Things (1983)

Score: 0

Diane Lane

as Nancy Wheeler in Stranger Things (1983)

Score: +1

Sally Field

as Joyce Byers in Stranger Things (1983)

Score: +1

Jennifer Connelly

as Jane Ives in Stranger Things (1983)

Score: +1

Shavar Ross

as Lucas Sinclair in Stranger Things (1983)

Score: +1

Barret Oliver

as Will Byers in Stranger Things (1983)

Score: +2

Sean Astin

as Mike Wheeler in Stranger Things (1983)

Score: +1

Harrison Ford

as Jim Hopper in Stranger Things (1983)

Score: +1

Robert Downey Jr.

as Eddie Munson in Stranger Things (1983)

Score: +1

Matt Dillon

as Steve Harrington in Stranger Things (1983)

Score: +1

Ke Huy Quan

as Dustin Henderson in Stranger Things (1983)

Score: 0

Ke Huy Quan

as Dustin Henderson in Stranger Things (late 80's)

Score: +4

Paul Newman

as Martin Brenner in Stranger Things (1986)

Score: +12