Suggestions by @mishafitt

Holly Marie Combs

as Linda McCullough in Little Fires Everywhere

Score: +4

Patrick Wilson

as Bill Richardson in Little Fires Everywhere

Score: +3

Philippa Northeast

as Violet Lasting in The Jewel (The Lone City Series)

Score: -4

Skai Jackson

as Pearl Warren in Little Fires Everywhere

Score: -3

Ty Simpkins

as Moody Richardson in Little Fires Everywhere

Score: +1

Logan Shroyer

as Trip Richardson in Little Fires Everywhere

Score: +4

Madison Iseman

as Lexie Richardson in Little Fires Everywhere

Score: +6

Kerry Washington

as Mia Warren in Little Fires Everywhere

Score: +1

Reese Witherspoon

as Elena Richardson in Little Fires Everywhere

Score: +3

Lilly Van Der Meer

as Rachel Amber in Life Is Strange

Score: -11

Isa Briones

as Max Caulfield in Life Is Strange

Score: -17

Sofia Hublitz

as Chloe Price in Life Is Strange

Score: -19

Amanda Leighton

as Kate Marsh in Life Is Strange

Score: -6

Ted Danson

as Richard in The Couple Next Door

Score: -1

Jane Krakowski

as Joyce Price in Life Is Strange

Score: -3

Lily Loveless

as Chloe Price in Life Is Strange

Score: -19

David Arquette

as David Madsen in Life Is Strange

Score: -8

Giovanni Ribisi

as David Madsen in Life Is Strange

Score: -3

Megan Fox

as Cynthia in The Couple Next Door

Score: +11

Kristen Bell

as Anne in The Couple Next Door

Score: -3