Suggestions by @mishafitt

Bellamy Young

as Rose Amber in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: +1

Thylane Blondeau

as Avery Fuller in The Thousandth Floor Series

Score: +4

Shelby Lyon

as Steph Gingrich in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: +1

Keith Powers

as Drew North in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: +1

Kara Hayward

as Steph Gingrich in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: -1

Maia Mitchell

as Steph Gingrich in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: +2

Emma Dumont

as Chloe Price in Life Is Strange

Score: -11

Emma Dumont

as Chloe Price in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: +2

Cozi Zuehlsdorff

as Victoria Chase in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: 0

Timothy Olyphant

as James Amber in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: +1

Kate Beckinsale

as Rose Amber in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: -1

Colin Farrell

as David Madsen in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: -1

Jaime King

as Sera Gearhardt in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: +3

Parker Mack

as Eliot Hampden in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: +1

Skeet Ulrich

as Damon Merrick in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: +5

Mark Pellegrino

as Frank Bowers in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: 0

Jane Krakowski

as Joyce Price in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: +1

Lilly Van Der Meer

as Rachel Amber in Life Is Strange: Before The Storm

Score: +5

Holladay Crook

as Izzy Richardson in Little Fires Everywhere

Score: -3

Li Qin

as Bebe Chow in Little Fires Everywhere

Score: 0