Suggestions by @miagothatexoxo

Jack Dylan Grazer

as Jake in American Horror Stories Recast

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Erin 2 in American Horror Stories Recast

Marisha Wallace

as Jules in American Horror Stories Recast

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as Charlie in American Horror Stories Recast

Ella Rubin

as Dani in American Horror Stories Recast

Mia Goth

as Sam in American Horror Stories Recast

Jack Innanen

as Jesse in American Horror Stories Recast

Constance Wu

as Poppy in American Horror Stories Recast

F. Murray Abraham

as Mr. Henderson in American Horror Stories Recast

Emma Roberts

as Fay Mallow in American Horror Stories Recast

Meryl Streep

as Cassie Brooks in American Horror Stories Recast

Léa Seydoux

as Dr. Enid Perle in American Horror Stories Recast

Laura Dern

as Virginia Mallow in American Horror Stories Recast

Stellan Skarsgård

as Bernie in American Horror Stories Recast

Diamond White

as Lena Lawrence in American Horror Stories Recast

PinkPantheress

as Bianca in American Horror Stories Recast

Morgan Dudley

as Maggie in American Horror Stories Recast

China Anne McClain

as Elise in American Horror Stories Recast

Josie Totah

as Anna in American Horror Stories Recast

Josh Brolin

as Historian in American Horror Stories Recast