Suggestions by @miagothatexoxo

Aramis Knight

as Toby Arcaño in American Horror Stories Recast

Jennifer Coolidge

as Sheila Klein in American Horror Stories Recast

Bowen Yang

as Dr. Thaddeus Lau in American Horror Stories Recast

Zendaya

as Vivian Lee Finch in American Horror Stories Recast

Nell Verlaque

as Heather Billings in American Horror Stories Recast

Luke Evans

as Tom Levitt in American Horror Stories Recast

Margot Robbie

as Sarah Miller in American Horror Stories Recast

Emma Stone

as Daphne in American Horror Stories Recast

Tim Meadows

as Detective in American Horror Stories Recast

Theo James

as Will Caswell in American Horror Stories Recast

Adrien Brody

as Guy Brubaker in American Horror Stories Recast

Madelyn Cline

as Bestie in American Horror Stories Recast

Daniel Brühl

as Mr. Nevins in American Horror Stories Recast

Omar Ayuso

as Anna Rexhia in American Horror Stories Recast

Armani Jackson

as River Wallace in American Horror Stories Recast

Chappell Roan

as Shelby Brubaker in American Horror Stories Recast

Laurence Fishburne

as Sheriff Maldack in American Horror Stories Recast

Wyatt Russell

as Jeffrey in American Horror Stories Recast

Carrie Preston

as Millie Boone in American Horror Stories Recast

Anna Lore

as Finn in American Horror Stories Recast