Suggestions by @maxhedroom

David Bowie

as Max Shreck in David Lynch’s Batman Duology (1989-1992)

Score: +11

Miguel Ferrer

as Alexander Knox in David Lynch’s Batman Duology (1989-1992)

Score: +11

Bokeem Woodbine

as Major Garland Briggs in Twin Peaks

Score: +3

Ahmed Best

as Hermes Conrad in Futurama

Score: +3

Malcolm McDowell

as Dr. Jack Seward in Bram Stoker's Dracula (1982)

Score: +2

Peter O'Toole

as Professor Abraham Van Helsing in Bram Stoker's Dracula (1982)

Score: +3

Tom Berenger

as Quincey P. Morris in Bram Stoker's Dracula (1982)

Score: +2

John Cusack

as Johnny Smith in The Dead Zone (2003)

Score: +3

Clifton Collins Jr.

as Bender Bending Rodriguez in Futurama

Score: +4

Wallace Shawn

as Professor Hubert J. Farnsworth in Futurama

Score: +8

Jon Voight

as Professor Hubert J. Farnsworth in Futurama

Score: +6

Anthony Hopkins

as Professor Hubert J. Farnsworth in Futurama

Score: +5

Robert Duvall

as Professor Hubert J. Farnsworth in Futurama

Score: +4

Morgan Freeman

as Professor Hubert J. Farnsworth in Futurama

Score: +4

Jared Leto

as Roberto in Futurama

Score: 0

Tim Blake Nelson

as Hyper-Chicken Lawyer in Futurama

Score: +3

Dave Bautista

as Morbo in Futurama

Score: +5

Vincent D'Onofrio

as The Donbot in Futurama

Score: +6

Andy Serkis

as Hypnotoad in Futurama

Score: +4

John Cusack

as Richard Nixon in Futurama

Score: +7