Suggestions by @matthew05

Manny Jacinto

as Jim Halpert in The Office: Almost Cast

Score: +1

Charles Melton

as Jim Halpert in The Office: Almost Cast

Score: +2

Michael Cusack

as Michael Scott in The Office: Almost Cast

Score: +2

Matthew Lillard

as Michael Scott in The Office: Almost Cast

Score: +2

Mark Ruffalo

as Michael Scott in The Office: Almost Cast

Score: +1

Jeremy Strong

as Michael Scott in The Office: Almost Cast

Score: +1

P.J. Byrne

as Michael Scott in The Office: Almost Cast

Score: +1

Bruce Campbell

as Michael Scott in The Office: Almost Cast

Score: +2

Danny McBride

as Michael Scott in The Office: Almost Cast

Score: +1

John Mulaney

as Michael Scott in The Office: Almost Cast

Score: +3

Adam Scott

as Michael Scott in The Office: Almost Cast

Score: +2

Trey Parker

as Michael Scott in The Office: Almost Cast

Score: +2

Bill Hader

as Michael Scott in The Office: Almost Cast

Score: +3

Jesse Plemons

as Michael Scott in The Office: Almost Cast

Score: +2

Madelyn Cline

as Invisible Woman in Ultimate Fantastic Four (2024 - 2029)

Score: +4

Laura Bailey

as Black Cat in New Voice Actors to Play Marvel and DC Characters

Score: +4

Linda Cardellini

as Gwen Stacy in New Voice Actors to Play Marvel and DC Characters

Score: +4

Jack De Sena

as Bobby Drake in Avengers: Total Superhero Team Control (Part 2)

Score: +2

Lacey Chabert

as Anna Marie in Avengers: Total Superhero Team Control (Part 2)

Score: +2

Laura Bailey

as Black Cat in Avengers: Total Superhero Team Control (Part 2)

Score: +2