Suggestions by @martinandrew

Isabel May

as Emily Nielson in The Skies of September

Score: -1

Valentina Cervi

as Vesper Lynd in Casino Royale but with "True Blood" actors

Score: +1

Mizuo Peck

as Jane^ in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Richard Thomas

as Brian Clark * in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Taylor Kalupa

as Heather Penney* in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Colin Quinn

as Ben Sliney * in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Pearl Scott

as CeeCee Lyles* in The Skies of September

Score: -1

Mizuo Peck

as Joan^ in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Renae Geerlings

as Debbie Welsh* in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Renae Geerlings

as Sandra Bradshaw* in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Martin Gargaro

as Writer in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Martin Gargaro

as Todd Beamer* in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Lisa Brenner

as Joan^ in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Vince Vaughn

as Lt. Charles Warren^ in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Mark Wahlberg

as Lt. Charles Warren^ in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Karley Scott Collins

as Composer in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Hans Zimmer

as Composer in The Skies of September

Score: -1

Enya

as Composer in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Robert Capron

as Robert O'Malley in The Skies of September

Score: +1

Skyler Gisondo

as Robert O'Malley in The Skies of September

Score: +1