Suggestions by @lorog

Yahya Abdul-Mateen II

as Childs in Horror Recast

Score: +2

Reneé Rapp

as Clear Rivers in Horror Recast

Score: +3

Sam Rechner

as Carter Blake in Horror Recast

Score: +2

Florian Munteanu

as Jason Voorhees in Horror Recast

Score: +2

Rupert Grint

as Shaun in Horror Recast

Score: +2

Harris Dickinson

as Westley in Almost Cast: The Princess Bride

Score: +1

Logan Lerman

as R.J. MacReady in Horror Recast

Score: +2

Anthony Hopkins

as Samuel Loomis in Horror Recast

Score: +2

Bill Skarsgård

as Michael Myers in Horror Recast

Score: +2

Lucy Boynton

as Marion Crane in Horror Recast

Score: +3

Lance Barber

as Uncle Ben Parker in Richman’s: Human Spider (2025)

Score: +3

Robert Sean Leonard

as Uncle Ben Parker in Richman’s: Human Spider (2025)

Score: +4

Ethan Hawke

as J. Jonah Jameson in Richman’s: Human Spider (2025)

Score: +2

Oliver Platt

as Doctor Octopus/Doc Ock in Richman’s: Human Spider (2025)

Score: +3

Chloe East

as Mary-Jane Watson in Richman’s: Human Spider (2025)

Score: +4

Talia Ryder

as Mary-Jane Watson in Richman’s: Human Spider (2025)

Score: +4

Jennifer Connelly

as Aunt May Parker in Richman’s: Human Spider (2025)

Score: +5

Louis Partridge

as Human Spider/Spider-Man in Richman’s: Human Spider (2025)

Score: -1

Anthony Turpel

as Human Spider/Spider-Man in Richman’s: Human Spider (2025)

Score: +2

Talia Ryder

as Han Solo in Solo: Rule 63

Score: +4