Suggestions by @lorog

Brad Garrett

as The Houndfather in The Ninja: In The Demon's Hand

Score: +1

Lewis Tan

as The Ninja in The Ninja: In The Demon's Hand

Score: +1

Josh Hartnett

as Superman in Superman Lives (2005)

Score: +2

Josh Hartnett

as Superman in Christopher Nolan's Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice (2010)

Score: +1

Diane Kruger

as Lilly Dillon in The Grifters

Score: +2

Patrick Gibson

as Norman Bates in Horror Recast

Score: +2

Devon Sawa

as Jack Torrance in Horror Recast

Score: +3

Samara Weaving

as Sue in Horror Recast

Score: +3

Hugh Laurie

as Mr. Reed in Horror Recast

Score: +3

Diane Lane

as Elisabeth Sparkle in Horror Recast

Score: +2

Diego Tinoco

as Dean Winchester in Horror Recast

Score: +2

Talia Ryder

as Sister Paxton in Horror Recast

Score: +3

Phoebe Dynevor

as Ellen Hutter in Horror Recast

Score: +3

Jamie Campbell Bower

as Count Orlok / Nosferatu in Horror Recast

Score: +2

Caleb McLaughlin

as Chris in Horror Recast

Score: +2

Violet McGraw

as Jamie Lloyd in Horror Recast

Score: +3

Rupert Friend

as Pennywise in Horror Recast

Score: +2

Walker Scobell

as Cole in Horror Recast

Score: +3

Austin Butler

as David in Horror Recast

Score: +2

David Mazouz

as Kale Brecht in Horror Recast

Score: +2