Suggestions by @kumagom

Leon Thomas III

as Desmond Irie in MPGiS

Score: -1

Joel McHale

as Doctor Cullen in MPGiS

Score: +1

Liam Hemsworth

as Doctor Cullen in MPGiS

Score: -1

Tinsley Price

as Gwen Kindle in MPGiS

Score: +1

Dakota Fanning

as Gwen Kindle in MPGiS

Score: -1

Anneliese Van Der Pol

as Jayna Van Buren in MPGiS

Score: +2

Park Bom

as Jeannie Halverstad in MPGiS

Score: +1

Barbara Palvin

as Jenna Dapananian in MPGiS

Score: -1

Molly C. Quinn

as Jenna Darabond in MPGiS

Score: +1

Emma Stone

as Jenna Darabond in MPGiS

Score: -1

Lily-Rose Depp

as Jennifer McMinnimen in MPGiS

Score: +1

Ashley French

as Jennifer McMinnimen in MPGiS

Score: -1

Neels Visser

as Jonathan Getslinhaumer in MPGiS

Score: +1

Lucas Till

as Jonathan Getslinhaumer in MPGiS

Score: -1

Joey King

as Judith Dinsmore in MPGiS

Score: +1

Jessica Stroup

as Judith Dinsmore in MPGiS

Score: -2

Benjamin Lasnier

as Justin Michaelson in MPGiS

Score: +1

Niall Horan

as Justin Michaelson in MPGiS

Score: -2

Kim Seo-Young

as Katelynn Zales in MPGiS

Score: +1

Mackenzie Foy

as Katelynn Zales in MPGiS

Score: -2