Suggestions by @kumagom

Pete Wentz

as Bert Hickey in MPGiS

Score: -1

Mitch Tummel

as Blaine McClaine in MPGiS

Score: +2

Ross Lynch

as Blaine McClaine in MPGiS

Score: -2

Josh Bowman

as Blake Jensen in MPGiS

Score: +1

Matt Bomer

as Blake Jensen in MPGiS

Score: -1

Emma Roberts

as Bridget Tice in MPGiS

Score: +2

Ashlee Simpson

as Bridget Tice in MPGiS

Score: -2

Lennon Stella

as Brittnay Matthews in MPGiS

Score: +1

Hayden Panettiere

as Brittnay Matthews in MPGiS

Score: -3

Son Sa-Rang

as Brooklyn Katchadorian in MPGiS

Score: +1

Ciara Bravo

as Brooklyn Katchadorian in MPGiS

Score: -1

Hailey Bieber

as Cameron Van Buren in MPGiS

Score: +3

Cassie Scerbo

as Cameron Van Buren in MPGiS

Score: -2

Desmond Harrington

as Coach Spitz in MPGiS

Score: +1

Scott Disick

as Coach Spitz in MPGiS

Score: -1

Jack Gilinsky

as Connor Devarnan in MPGiS

Score: +1

Grant Gustin

as Connor Devarnan in MPGiS

Score: -1

Meg Donnelly

as Deandra The New Girl in MPGiS

Score: 0

Amanda Seyfried

as Deandra The New Girl in MPGiS

Score: -1

Winston Duke

as Desmond Irie in MPGiS

Score: +1