Suggestions by @johnlukeglee

Johnlukeglee

as Clay Jensen in 13 Reasons Why (2012-present)

Score: -1

Ted King

as Husband Shroud leader in Justice League Dark (1997)

Score: +1

Drew Fuller

as Merlin in Justice League Dark (1997)

Score: +2

Jennifer Rhodes

as Swamp Thing in Justice League Dark (1997)

Score: +1

Kaley Cuoco

as Etigan the demon in Justice League Dark (1997)

Score: +2

Brian Krause

as John Constantine in Justice League Dark (1997)

Score: +2

Shannen Doherty

as Zatanna in Justice League Dark (1997)

Score: +2

Brian Austin Green

as Batman in Justice League Dark (1997)

Score: +1

Brian Austin Green

as Kronos in 🔱Percy Jackson and the Olympians🔱

Score: -7

Ian Ziering

as Ares in 🔱Percy Jackson and the Olympians🔱

Score: -14

Daniel Cosgrove

as Dionysus in 🔱Percy Jackson and the Olympians🔱

Score: -16

James Eckhouse

as Charon in 🔱Percy Jackson and the Olympians🔱

Score: -4

Gabrielle Carteris

as Atropos in 🔱Percy Jackson and the Olympians🔱

Score: +6

Kate Micucci

as Lachesis in 🔱Percy Jackson and the Olympians🔱

Score: +3

Demi Moore

as Lachesis in 🔱Percy Jackson and the Olympians🔱

Score: +12

Bradley Whitford

as Chiron in 🔱Percy Jackson and the Olympians🔱

Score: -12

Sofia Carson

as Nancy Bobofit in 🔱Percy Jackson and the Olympians🔱

Score: -34

KJ Apa

as Percy Jackson in 🔱Percy Jackson and the Olympians🔱

Score: -60

Mark Consuelos

as Producer in 🔱Percy Jackson and the Olympians🔱

Score: -6

Casey Cott

as Director in 🔱Percy Jackson and the Olympians🔱

Score: -7