Suggestions by @johnlukeglee

Imelda Staunton

as Jeremiah Valeska in Gotham (2005-2009)

Score: 0

Gina Gershon

as Jeremiah Valeska in Gotham (2005-2009)

Score: -1

Geraldine James

as Edward Nygma in Gotham (2005-2009)

Score: +1

Diego Luna

as Oswald Cobblepott in Gotham (2005-2009)

Score: +1

Felicity Jones

as Bruce Wayne in Gotham (2005-2009)

Score: -2

Pilou Asbæk

as Jim Gordon in Gotham (2005-2009)

Score: +1

Leah Lewis

as Alison in Pretty Little Liars

Score: +2

Kennedy McMann

as Spencer Hastings in Pretty Little Liars

Score: +1

Dan Jeannotte

as Saint George in 13 Reasons Why (2012-present)

Score: +1

Katie Stevens

as Neighborhood Boy in 13 Reasons Why (2012-present)

Score: +3

Evan Bittencourt

as Jeff Atkins in 13 Reasons Why (2012-present)

Score: +1

Sydney Park

as Kat in 13 Reasons Why (2012-present)

Score: +2

Sasha Pieterse

as Skye Miller in 13 Reasons Why (2012-present)

Score: 0

Eli Brown

as Matt Jensen in 13 Reasons Why (2012-present)

Score: +1

Jordan Connor

as Ryan Shaver in 13 Reasons Why (2012-present)

Score: +3

Marisol Nichols

as Lainie Jensen in 13 Reasons Why (2012-present)

Score: +5

Madelaine Petsch

as Courtney Crimsen in 13 Reasons Why (2012-present)

Score: +2

KJ Apa

as Antonio "Tony" Padilla in 13 Reasons Why (2012-present)

Score: -1

Johnlukeglee

as Montgomery De la Cruz in 13 Reasons Why (2012-present)

Score: +1

KJ Apa

as Clay Jensen in 13 Reasons Why (2012-present)

Score: +2