Suggestions by @jackkirker

Nina Dobrev

as Isobel Fleming in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Zach Roerig

as John Gilbert in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +2

Ethan Cutkosky

as Kol Mikealson in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Kalani Hilliker

as Hayley Marshall in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: -1

Wilbur Soot

as Elijah Mikealson in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: -1

Itzan Escamilla

as Elijah Mikealson in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +2

Elliot Fletcher

as Elijah Mikealson in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: -1

Meryl Streep

as Elizabeth Forbes in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: -2

Shawn Mendes

as Damon Salvatore in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Timothée Chalamet

as Stefan Salvatore in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Cobie Smulders

as Rayna Cruz in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +2

Harry Styles

as Klaus Mikealson in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: 0

Charlie Heaton

as Klaus Mikealson in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: 0

Penn Badgley

as Logan Fell in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Lana Del Rey

as Freya Mikealson in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Noah Schnapp

as Jeremy Gilbert in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Tom Holland

as Jeremy Gilbert in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: -1

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Logan Fell in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Michael Trevino

as Mayor Lockwood in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: 0

Louis Partridge

as Tyler Lockwood in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1