Suggestions by @jackkirker

Michael B. Jordan

as Vincent Griffith in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Chloë Grace Moretz

as Camille O' Connell in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: 0

Claire Holt

as Camille O' Connell in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: 0

Jennifer Morrison

as Elizabeth Forbes in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +3

Melissa Benoist

as Lexi Branson in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Jordan Fisher

as Marcel Gerard in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Selena Gomez

as Davina Claire in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Beyoncé

as Abby Wilson Bennett in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Katie McGrath

as Dahlia in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Amanda Seyfried

as Esther Mikealson in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: 0

Anne Hathaway

as Esther Mikealson in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: -1

Dianna Agron

as Esther Mikealson in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: 0

Lana Parrilla

as Antoinette Sienna in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Colin O'Donoghue

as Bill Forbes in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +2

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Giuseppe Salvatore in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Ginnifer Goodwin

as Lily Salvatore in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Lauren Cohan

as Jo Laughlin in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Tom Felton

as Finn Mikealson in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Emmy Rossum

as Hayley Marshall in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1

Emma Watson

as Rebekah Mikealson in The Vampire Diaries Recast

Score: +1