Suggestions by @irishbabe97
448 suggestions
Auliʻi Cravalho
as Whatsername in American Idiot
Score: +2
Lily James
as Whatsername in American Idiot
Score: +2
Daisy Ridley
as Whatsername in American Idiot
Score: +5
Brendon Urie
as Will in American Idiot
Score: +2
Taron Egerton
as Tunny in American Idiot
Score: +2
Eva Noblezada
as Extraordinary Girl in American Idiot
Score: 0
Reeve Carney
as Johnny in American Idiot
Score: +2
Reeve Carney
as Johnny in American Idiot
Score: 0
Reeve Carney
as Orpheus in Hadestown
Score: +4
Timothée Chalamet
as Christian Stovitz in Clueless (Musical Adaptation)
Score: +1
Timothy Spall
as Christian Stovitz in Clueless (Musical Adaptation)
Score: -3
Reeve Carney
as Josh Lucas in Clueless (Musical Adaptation)
Score: +2
Reeve Carney
as Fiyero in Wicked (2021)
Score: -4
Reeve Carney
as Jack Skellington in The Nightmare Before Christmas
Score: +1
Luke Evans
as Barkis Bittern in Corpse Bride (Stage Musical)(story removed)
Score: +1
Elizabeth Olsen
as Emily Merrimack in Corpse Bride (Stage Musical)(story removed)
Score: +1
Emilia Clarke
as Victoria Everglot in Corpse Bride (Stage Musical)(story removed)
Score: +1
Bill Skarsgård
as Victor Van Dort in Corpse Bride (Stage Musical)(story removed)
Score: +2
Colton Ryan
as Fiyero in Wicked (2021)
Score: -7
Ben Hardy
as Eros in Mythos
Score: -4