Suggestions by @irishbabe97

Rachel Zegler

as Christine Daae in Andrew Lloyd Webber's The Phantom of the Opera

Score: +2

Oscar Isaac

as Erik, The Phantom in The Phantom of the Opera

Score: 0

Florence Pugh

as Christine Daae in Andrew Lloyd Webber's The Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

Oscar Isaac

as The Phantom in Andrew Lloyd Webber's The Phantom of the Opera

Score: 0

Sydney Sweeney

as Lolita in Lolita

Score: -4

Oscar Isaac

as Prof. Humbert Humbert in Lolita

Score: -4

Oscar Isaac

as Jesus Christ in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: 0

Oscar Isaac

as Erik in The Phantom of the Opera

Score: +1

Ryan Gosling

as The Wolfman in Dark Universe

Score: +5

Mena Massoud

as Tunny in American Idiot

Score: 0

Naomi Scott

as Extraordinary Girl in American Idiot

Score: +1

Elizabeth Gillies

as Extraordinary Girl in American Idiot

Score: 0

Brie Larson

as Heather in American Idiot

Score: +3

Elizabeth Gillies

as Whatsername in American Idiot

Score: +1

Dove Cameron

as Heather in American Idiot

Score: +2

Julianne Hough

as Heather in American Idiot

Score: +2

Ariana Grande

as Extraordinary Girl in American Idiot

Score: +2

Zendaya

as Extraordinary Girl in American Idiot

Score: +5

Anna Kendrick

as Heather in American Idiot

Score: +1

Katharine McPhee

as Whatsername in American Idiot

Score: +2