Suggestions by @gmoore10

Michael Scott

as Near in Death Note but so bad

Score: +1

Evil James Corden

as Mello in Death Note but so bad

Score: +1

Cocaine Bear

as Watari in Death Note but so bad

Score: +1

Kat Dennings

as Lilith Vatore in The Sims 4

Score: -1

Diego Calva

as Diego Lobo in The Sims 4

Score: +1

Shameik Moore

as Cameron Fletcher in The Sims 4

Score: +3

Tony Revolori

as Rohan Elderberry in The Sims 4

Score: +1

Maitreyi Ramakrishnan

as Becca Clarke in The Sims 4

Score: -5

Jenna Ortega

as Cassandra Goth in The Sims 4

Score: +12

Bryce Dallas Howard

as Moira Fyres in The Sims 4

Score: +3

Sophia Lillis

as Morgan Fyres in The Sims 4

Score: -2

Nicholas Hoult

as Caleb Vatore in The Sims 4

Score: +2

Wes Anderson

as Director in The Sims 4

Score: +2

Willem Dafoe

as Jacques Villareal in The Sims 4

Score: +1

Dominique Thorne

as Julia Wright in The Sims 4

Score: 0

Bill Skarsgård

as Vladislaus Straud in The Sims 4

Score: 0

Timothée Chalamet

as Gunther Munch in The Sims 4

Score: +2

Adrien Brody

as Thorne Bailey in The Sims 4

Score: +1

Quinn Shephard

as Jade Rosa in The Sims 4

Score: +1

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Mimsy in The Sims 4

Score: +1