Suggestions by @gmoore10

Jurnee Smollett

as Penny Pizzazz in The Sims 4

Score: +2

Gong Yoo

as Victor Feng in The Sims 4

Score: +4

Alana Haim

as Ulrike Faust in The Sims 4

Score: +2

Pete Davidson

as Joaquin Le Chien in The Sims 4

Score: +2

Glen Powell

as Sergio Romeo in The Sims 4

Score: -3

Faithe Herman

as Olivia Kim-Lewis in The Sims 4

Score: +3

Toni Collette

as Clara Bjergsen in The Sims 4

Score: -3

Beanie Feldstein

as Maaike Haas in The Sims 4

Score: +1

John David Washington

as Eric Lewis in The Sims 4

Score: +2

Judah Lewis

as Wolfgang Munch in The Sims 4

Score: 0

Michaela Coel

as Anaya Jang in The Sims 4

Score: +1

Olivia Colman

as Mila Munch in The Sims 4

Score: +1

Julian Dennison

as Hugo Villareal in The Sims 4

Score: +1

Zoey Deutch

as Angela Pleasant in The Sims 4

Score: +3

Katherine McNamara

as Lilith Pleasant in The Sims 4

Score: +1

Austin Butler

as Johnny Zest in The Sims 4

Score: +5

Aaron Taylor-Johnson

as Superman in DCU fancast

Score: +1

Sebastian Stan

as Batman in DCU fancast

Score: 0

Keanu Reeves

as Batman in DCU fancast

Score: 0

lil huddy

as Misa in Death Note but so bad

Score: +1