Suggestions by @frachlitz

Billy Magnussen

as Jim Pomatter in Waitress

Score: +29

Laura Marano

as Jenna Hunterson in Waitress

Score: +26

Janet Hubert

as Hannah O’Rourke in Come From Away

Score: +2

Tatyana Ali

as Hannah O’Rourke in Come From Away

Score: +1

Ellen Greene

as Diane Gray in Come From Away

Score: +1

Jennifer Coolidge

as Beulah Davis in Come From Away

Score: +1

Haaz Sleiman

as Ali in Come From Away

Score: +1

Taran Killam

as Doug in Come From Away

Score: +1

Adam Pascal

as Garth in Come From Away

Score: +1

Brandy Norwood

as Hannah O’Rourke in Come From Away

Score: +1

Jayma Mays

as Janice Mosher in Come From Away

Score: +1

Jodi Benson

as Diane Gray in Come From Away

Score: +1

Jeremy Irons

as Nick Marson in Come From Away

Score: +1

Bowen Yang

as Kevin Jung in Come From Away

Score: +1

Andrew Rannells

as Kevin Tuerff in Come From Away

Score: +1

Elijah Kelley

as Bob in Come From Away

Score: +1

Christopher Jackson

as Claude Elliott in Come From Away

Score: +1

Yvette Nicole Brown

as Annette in Come From Away

Score: +1

Idina Menzel

as Beverly Bass in Come From Away

Score: +1

Hugh Skinner

as Oz Fudge in Come From Away

Score: +1